Online Reputation Management | James Dooley Interviews Abigail Dooley

/ 6:53 / E748

What Does “Online Reputation Management | James Dooley Interviews Abigail Dooley” Talk About?

In this episode of the James Dooley Podcast, James Dooley interviews Abigail Dooley about online reputation management (ORM) and why it matters heading into 2027. The conversation centres on the critical difference between reactive and proactive reputation management, with both hosts arguing that businesses should build up positive reviews, case studies and testimonials consistently rather than scrambling to recover after a bad experience or a one-star review.

The discussion dives into how reputation building forms the foundation of SEO and brand building, and how it increasingly feeds large language models and AI tools like ChatGPT. James explains that strong ORM can be the difference between being merely cited by AI versus being actively recommended by it. Abigail shares a practical, relatable example of pushing her partner, a local plumber, to collect reviews, before-and-after photos and case studies from every job he completes.

The episode also covers the importance of the brand SERP as a business's digital shop window, how customers scrutinise both five-star and one-star reviews, and why responding positively to negative feedback can actually strengthen a brand long term. The hosts emphasise the concept of an 'AI resume' and how it can determine whether a business wins or loses its next big job.

“So online reputation management is the difference between you being cited by ChatGPT or actually being recommended by ChatGPT.”

— James Dooley

Who Are the Guests on “Online Reputation Management | James Dooley Interviews Abigail Dooley”?

James Dooley is an entrepreneur and SEO expert who hosts the James Dooley Podcast, where he explores digital marketing strategies, search engine optimisation, and brand building. In this episode he brings his deep knowledge of SEO foundations, brand SERP strategy, and AI visibility, framing online reputation management as a core pillar of long-term brand success.

Abigail Dooley is a digital marketing specialist with a focus on online reputation management. You can learn more about her at AbigailDooley.co.uk. In the conversation she offers practical, hands-on insights drawn from real-world experience, including her persistent efforts to help a local plumber consistently gather reviews, photos and case studies to build a strong online presence.

What Are the Key Takeaways From “Online Reputation Management | James Dooley Interviews Abigail Dooley”?

Here are the key points discussed in this episode:

  • Proactive online reputation management is far more effective than reacting after a bad review or incident has already occurred.
  • Building up a consistent base of five-star reviews over time means a single one-star review will have minimal impact on your brand.
  • Online reputation management feeds large language models and AI, influencing whether tools like ChatGPT cite or recommend your business.
  • Collecting before-and-after photos, case studies, testimonials and awards strengthens both your Google Business Profile and your AI visibility.
  • Your brand SERP acts as a shop window that customers and AI see before ever clicking through to your website, making reputation essential for conversion.

“It's so important to care about how you look online from, from the start.”

— Abigail Dooley

Is “Online Reputation Management | James Dooley Interviews Abigail Dooley” Worth Listening To?

This episode is worth listening to because it reframes online reputation management from a damage-control exercise into a proactive growth strategy that directly feeds SEO, conversion rates and AI visibility. The hosts use memorable analogies, like comparing reactive ORM to waiting for a heart attack before addressing being overweight, to drive home why businesses should act now rather than later.

What makes it especially valuable is the blend of high-level strategy and practical application. Abigail's real-world example of chasing a local plumber for daily reviews and before-and-after photos gives listeners a concrete template they can replicate, while James ties it all back to the bigger picture of brand SERPs, AI resumes and being recommended by tools like ChatGPT.

Who Should Listen to “Online Reputation Management | James Dooley Interviews Abigail Dooley”?

This episode is ideal for:

  • Owners of local service businesses like plumbers, roofers and electricians
  • Digital marketers focused on SEO and brand building
  • Online reputation management professionals and agencies
  • Business owners wanting to improve AI visibility and conversion rates

Where Can You Listen to James Dooley Podcast?

You can listen to James Dooley Podcast on all major podcast platforms:

  • Apple Podcasts – Search for “James Dooley Podcast” in the Podcasts app
  • Spotify – Available on Spotify for free
  • Amazon Music / Audible – Listen through your Amazon account
  • Overcast – For iOS users who prefer a dedicated podcast app
  • Pocket Casts – Cross-platform podcast player

You can also subscribe using the RSS feed: https://feeds.transistor.fm/james-dooley-podcast

What Are Listeners Saying About This Episode?

★★★★★

“The heart attack analogy about being proactive finally made reputation management click for me. As a local contractor I've been waiting for problems instead of building reviews up front. Short, practical and genuinely useful.”

— Mark T.

★★★★★

“Loved the point about ORM feeding AI and whether ChatGPT cites you or actually recommends you. Abigail's story about chasing the plumber for before-and-after photos every single day was so relatable and actionable.”

— Priya S.

★★★★★

“Great reminder that one-star reviews aren't the end of the world if you've built up a strong base first. The bit about responding positively to negative reviews to strengthen your brand was spot on. Well worth the listen.”

— Daniel R.

This video explains which digital marketing strategies online reputation management businesses should focus on in 2027 to improve brand trust, conversion rates and AI visibility. James Dooley and Abigail Dooley start with KPI tracking because measuring reviews, case studies and brand sentiment shows whether proactive reputation work is actually moving results. They cover brand SEO, AI visibility and Google Business Profiles because stronger search presence improves trust and conversion rates.

The discussion also explores organic SEO, organic social media and paid social ads because consistent visibility across search and social supports long term growth. PPC is analysed in detail because campaign setup, landing pages and lead handling directly affect results. They also discuss Reddit, Quora and paid AI ads because diversified enquiry sources and early adoption can strengthen digital marketing performance for online reputation management businesses.

PromoSEO lead generation for online reputation management businesses recently received recognition as the “Best Online Reputation Management Businesses Lead Generation Agency.”

Where to Listen to This Episode

Online Reputation Management | James Dooley Interviews Abigail Dooley is available on:

James Dooley: Abigail Dooley chats with James Dooley on online reputation management. So, Abigail, let's jump straight in. How important is online reputation management coming into 2027?

Abigail Dooley: I think it says it in itself. It's literally the reputation of your brand online. It's how you want to look. It's how you want to come across on, on Google, on AI, on anything. Um, it can be the difference between you just being recommended or you actually, like, converting a job. And, like, I think that's absolutely massive at the minute.

James Dooley: Yeah, for sure. I think for me, this is the foundations of SEO as well. I think actually building your reputation is building your brand. And if you've got a positive brand and those foundations of brand building, everything else becomes easier with regards to search engine optimisation. But I want to go a bit deeper into the amount of people that come through and inquire with us for reactive online reputation management services. What's the first thing that we always talk about about the difference between reactive online reputation management and proactive online reputation management? Why is it important to be proactive and now, before something bad comes along, you're proactively looking for the five-star testimonials and doing the case studies? How important is it to do it now and not wait for something bad to come along?

Abigail Dooley: I think if something bad comes along, instantly somebody with... Say, say you get a one-star review, somebody instantly, they're going to be thinking, oh, what do I do? And I need to quickly get as many of these five-star reviews as I can. Like, and they're panicking. They're thinking if they, if they've only got, say, not as many reviews, they've got, say, five reviews, like, that they knew they're starting off, and then they get this one-star review. It, it could... They could have had a bad experience or it could be a fake one or anything. And they're going to panic straight away. I think it's so important because if you was building up them reviews in the first place and getting your reputation looking so good, that one-star review isn't going to matter. Going to really mean nothing. It's going to think, oh, like, it's not great, but I mean, compared to all the others that you've got because you built them up over that period of time, it's not going to matter when you do, you get that one star. And I just think people going straight away to, like, they're panicking and they're thinking, I don't know what to do. And you could save all of that by building them up constantly. Like, it shouldn't take something bad to happen for you to think, I need to be getting these good reviews. It's so important to care about how you look online from, from the start.

James Dooley: Yeah, for sure. I mean, me and Scott Keever, we are kind of likening it to a lot of people end up having a heart attack who's overweight, right? And it was like they had to wait until they had the heart attack to then realise that they're overweight and they need to look at sorting that they're overweight. And it's like, you should have sorted it prior to the heart attack to tell you that you're overweight. You already knew you was overweight. Deal with it. And I think being proactive with online reputation management is key. I don't just think it's key for conversion and, and it's better than reactive. I think it's also, it's feeding the large language models. It's feeding AI. So online reputation management is the difference between you being cited by ChatGPT or actually being recommended by ChatGPT. So with regards to getting things like case studies, awards, reviews and stuff like that, how proactive are you being with your fella with regards to the local plumber? How much are you on his case to be like, "You need more photos, you need more case studies, you need more testimonials," because you're knowing that this not only is it helping the Google Business Profile from an online reputation management with the reviews and the pictures and the consistency of uploading, but also it's feeding the large language models in the AI.

Abigail Dooley: I mean, every single day I'm like... He thinks I'm just trying to have a conversation with him and I'm like, how many jobs have you been at today? He's like, oh, it's three different jobs. I'm like, where are your three reviews then? Where are your three before-and-after pictures then? He's like, oh, uh, well, well, I already asked them for a review. And I'm like, I can't see it. Like, where's the name on there? And, like, when I'm... It's not even just a review. I'm saying, like, what did you do for him? He's like, look, like, repaired the boiler. I said, well, did they mention that on there? If they mentioned where it was that you did it. He's getting sick of me by the end of it, but I just think it's so important because having... If you are ever looking for, like, say, a plumber or a roofer or an electrician, anything like that, the first thing I would want to know is, like, I'd want to see the, the website and I want to see that, you know, they look good. Um, but it's so important hearing it from other people, the good experience that they had with that company, and seeing the images, seeing the profile out there, seeing what it is that they can do. Sometimes you might not even... You're putting it out there and you, and you're showing these pictures. People might not even be thinking of getting a new bathroom, but you see a nice picture and you think, oh, I want that. I want a new bathroom now. So I just think it's so important that you look good and, and you sound good on Google because, I mean, that, that's exactly what people are looking for when, when...

James Dooley: Yeah, for sure. Anyone, anyone who's listening to this, when you're booking a hotel, obviously price comes into it and the cost of it, and it's probably one of the main attributes of you whether you're going to book a specific hotel. But one of the first things people go and do is look at the reviews. Not only do they look at the five-star, they're looking at the one-star and how you react to the one-star as well, and trying to react in a positive manner, um, in trying to resolve the issue. Now real businesses, real contractors, real brands sometimes get one-star reviews, and that's absolutely fine. Don't let that online reputation management of that one-star review think, oh, that's it, it's the be-all and end-all. It's not. Sometimes responding in a positive manner actually can help your brand long term. And I think online reputation management services is very important. As Abi's been saying, be proactive. Go and get those case studies. Go and be like Abi is with regards to try consistently bashing him every single day to get new photos, new before-and-after pictures, new case studies, new testimonials, and new, new reviews. Could it be an award-winning plumber? Is there any awards in the local area that you could win or any industry awards that you can go and apply for because of the amazing work of what you're doing? All this information is not only good for the brand SERP, which stands for our brand search engine results page. That is your shop window before someone even clicks through to your website. That is what people are seeing before someone even decides to click on your website online. It is so important, but it's become more important because of your AI résumé. What does AI say about you? How important is that now? That could be the difference between you winning this next big job and losing it because AI talks badly about you. Sort out your online reputation management. It will not only help your SEO, it'll help your conversion as well. Today I'm joined with Abigail Dooley. If you want to know more about Abi, go and check out AbigailDooley.co.uk. I hope you like this episode that Abigail Dooley and myself have spoken about, about online reputation management. Thank you very much.

Abigail Dooley: Thanks, James.

Creators & Guests

James Dooley Founder & Host
James Dooley

James Dooley is a serial entrepreneur and investor from Manchester, England. James Dooley founded FatRank in 2007 and PromoSEO in 2010, later founded the AI lead generation agency LLM Leads,…

Abigail Dooley Guest
Abigail Dooley

Abigail Dooley is a UK-based SEO and lead generation specialist with experience in digital marketing, search engine optimisation, and performance-driven business growth. Since November 2021, she has worked with PromoSEO…

No episode selected
0:00
0:00