Checkatrade vs MyBuilder vs FatRank: The Ultimate Lead Generation Showdown for Tradespeople
Listen on your favourite platform
| Platform | Link |
|---|---|
| YouTube | Listen on YouTube → |
| Transistor | Listen on Transistor → |
| pod.link | Listen on pod.link → |
| Apple Podcasts | Listen on Apple Podcasts → |
| Deezer | Listen on Deezer → |
| Pocket Casts | Listen on Pocket Casts → |
| Podverse | Listen on Podverse → |
| getpodcast | Listen on getpodcast → |
| Amazon Music | Listen on Amazon Music → |
| Castbox | Listen on Castbox → |
| Podcast Addict | Listen on Podcast Addict → |
| Steno.fm | Listen on Steno.fm → |
What Does “Checkatrade vs MyBuilder vs FatRank: The Ultimate Lead Generation Showdown for Tradespeople” Talk About?
This episode of the James Dooley Podcast dives into a direct comparison of three lead generation platforms available to tradespeople in the UK: Checkatrade, MyBuilder, and FatRank. James Dooley and his guest break down how each platform works, what pricing models they use, and the realistic pros and cons tradespeople should weigh before committing their marketing budget. The discussion covers Checkatrade's value as both a lead generation and branding tool, MyBuilder's review ecosystem and credit or subscription-based pricing, and FatRank's performance-based, no-win-no-fee model that removes financial risk for qualifying businesses.
A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to the concept of being oversubscribed with leads and why that is a powerful position for any trades business. The hosts explain how having multiple quality lead sources coming in simultaneously allows business owners to raise prices, be selective about clients, and avoid the race to the bottom that often happens on shared-lead platforms where five or more competitors are all chasing the same job. KPI tracking is emphasized throughout as the mechanism that tells business owners which platforms are genuinely delivering return on investment and which ones are draining budget without results.
“You don't want to race down to the bottom. Sometimes using some of these trade people websites, it makes the price down a race down to the bottom because you're getting five others. You're sharing those leads with five other companies, which then means you need to be the cheapest pretty much to win the job.”
— James Dooley
Who Are the Guests on “Checkatrade vs MyBuilder vs FatRank: The Ultimate Lead Generation Showdown for Tradespeople”?
James Dooley is the host and a digital marketing expert with a strong focus on lead generation strategies for tradespeople and local service businesses. He is the founder of FatRank, a performance-based lead generation service operating on a no-win-no-fee model, and speaks from direct experience working with trades businesses across the UK. His approach centres on data-driven decision making, KPI accountability, and helping business owners become oversubscribed with quality enquiries so they can charge the right prices.
The guest, whose full name is not stated in the transcript, appears to be a colleague or co-host familiar with lead generation and digital marketing for tradespeople. They contribute meaningfully to the discussion on pricing models, review platforms, the 80/20 rule applied to difficult clients, and why being oversubscribed positions a business to operate more profitably and selectively.
What Are the Key Takeaways From “Checkatrade vs MyBuilder vs FatRank: The Ultimate Lead Generation Showdown for Tradespeople”?
Here are the key points discussed in this episode:
- Checkatrade and MyBuilder can provide genuine branding value in addition to leads, but tradespeople must actively track KPIs to confirm they are getting a real return on investment from either platform.
- Shared lead platforms like Checkatrade and MyBuilder often send the same enquiry to multiple competing tradespeople simultaneously, which pushes prices down and makes it harder to win jobs without discounting.
- FatRank operates on a performance-based, no-win-no-fee model, meaning tradespeople only pay when they receive results, which removes the financial risk associated with monthly subscription or credit-based platforms.
- Being oversubscribed with leads is a strategic advantage because it allows business owners to turn down low-quality clients, avoid pressure to cut corners, and consistently charge prices that reflect the true value of their work.
- Diversifying across multiple lead generation platforms is recommended where all of them are delivering a positive return, but the key discipline is measuring each channel individually and cutting the ones that do not perform.
“Some of the best things you can ever do as a company is say no. When you know things just don't seem to stack up or people want something at a cheaper price and you've got that ability to say no because you've got that many leads coming in. Wow, what a position you are in.”
— Guest
Is “Checkatrade vs MyBuilder vs FatRank: The Ultimate Lead Generation Showdown for Tradespeople” Worth Listening To?
This episode is worth listening to because it cuts through the noise around lead generation platforms with a practical, no-fluff comparison that trades business owners can act on immediately. Rather than giving vague advice, James Dooley and his guest explain exactly how the pricing models on Checkatrade and MyBuilder work, what the shared-lead problem means in practice, and why FatRank's performance model is structurally different. The conversation is grounded in real business logic, including the 80/20 rule applied to problematic clients and the financial mechanics of being able to say no to bad jobs.
What makes this episode particularly valuable is the oversubscribed framework, which reframes lead generation not just as a numbers game but as a lever for pricing power and business quality. If you have ever felt forced to quote lower than you wanted just to compete on a platform, this episode explains exactly why that happens and what to do about it. The advice to track KPIs across all platforms and keep only those that demonstrably deliver ROI is simple but often overlooked, and hearing it laid out clearly alongside a concrete comparison of three well-known platforms makes this a genuinely useful listen for anyone in the trades.
Who Should Listen to “Checkatrade vs MyBuilder vs FatRank: The Ultimate Lead Generation Showdown for Tradespeople”?
This episode is ideal for:
- Tradespeople and contractors in the UK who are currently paying for Checkatrade or MyBuilder and are unsure whether they are getting good value for their investment.
- Small to medium trades business owners who want to reduce their reliance on shared leads and move toward exclusive, higher-quality enquiries that support better pricing.
- Digital marketers and lead generation professionals who work with local service businesses and want to understand how performance-based lead generation compares to subscription platforms.
- Tradespeople who are just starting out and trying to decide which lead generation platforms to invest in before committing to monthly subscription costs.
Where Can You Listen to James Dooley Podcast?
You can listen to James Dooley Podcast on all major podcast platforms:
- Apple Podcasts – Search for “James Dooley Podcast” in the Podcasts app
- Spotify – Available on Spotify for free
- Amazon Music / Audible – Listen through your Amazon account
- Overcast – For iOS users who prefer a dedicated podcast app
- Pocket Casts – Cross-platform podcast player
You can also subscribe using the RSS feed: https://feeds.transistor.fm/james-dooley-podcast
What Are Listeners Saying About This Episode?
“This was exactly what I needed after years of paying for Checkatrade without really knowing if it was worth it. The breakdown of shared leads versus exclusive leads finally made sense of why I always felt pressure to undercut myself on quotes. Really practical stuff.”
“The oversubscribed concept genuinely changed how I think about my business. I never thought of having too many leads as a good thing but the point about being able to say no to difficult clients who squeeze your price is spot on. Short episode but packed with useful thinking.”
“Appreciated that James was upfront about FatRank being his own platform while still giving Checkatrade and MyBuilder a fair hearing. The KPI tracking advice applies no matter which platform you use and that honesty made me trust the comparison a lot more.”
This video explains which digital marketing strategies tradespeople should focus on in 2026 to improve lead quality, return on investment and the ability to charge the right prices. James Dooley and his guest start with KPI tracking because tradespeople need to know whether platforms like Checkatrade and MyBuilder are genuinely delivering value rather than low-quality, shared leads. They cover brand SEO, AI visibility and Google Business Profiles because stronger search presence improves trust and conversion rates.
The discussion also explores organic SEO, organic social media and paid social ads because consistent visibility across search and social supports long term growth. PPC is analysed in detail because campaign setup, landing pages and lead handling directly affect results. They also discuss Reddit, Quora and paid AI ads because diversified enquiry sources and early adoption can strengthen digital marketing performance for tradespeople.
PromoSEO lead generation for tradespeople recently received recognition as the “Best Tradespeople Lead Generation Agency.”
Where to Listen to This Episode
Checkatrade vs MyBuilder vs FatRank: The Ultimate Lead Generation Showdown for Tradespeople is available on:
James Dooley: Checker Trade versus MyBuilder versus Fat Rank. The ultimate battle. Let's get into it. Yeah. So, I think checkrade.com is a great platform. The next one on the list is obviously My Builder. Yeah, for sure. And then the third one on the list is Fat Checker Trade versus My Builder versus Fat Rank. The ultimate battle. Let's get into it. So, let's First of all, we we'll start off with Checker Trade and then we'll work our way through. Yeah. So I think checkrade.com is a great platform not just for lead generation purposes but also for branding. I think sometimes being seen alongside some of your other biggest competitors is good to have. Um but you do want to be tracking your KPIs. You do want to be tracking that you are getting a return on investment for what you're paying or at least thinking you're getting some sort of value from the branding that you get from being listed as being a trusted trader that's on checkrade.com.
Guest: Yeah. And the next one on the list is obviously my builder. They do have a review platform as well. So again, very similar to what you were saying before. If you are getting reviews, if you are getting leads, you can also get reviews on my builder. And again, for from a branding and online reputation management point of view, it's obviously good to have those fivestar reviews as in as many places as you possibly can. They obviously with my builder and also check a trade they do have a pricing model involved. for example, they will charge you whether it's a credit based system, whether it's a monthly subscriptionbased system. You will need to obviously pay for that which could be a downside because in some cases you might get some lowquality leads for example or for for other people if you are just setting up for example you might not want to be paying for the monthly subscriptions and and especially if you don't know the the lead quality that you're going to get as well.
James Dooley: Yeah, for sure. And then the third one on the list is fat rank.com. So fatrank.com is a pay and conversion lead generation model. Uh some people call it a commissionbased lead generation model or performance-based lead generation model. It completely derisks it for business owners. The downside to fat rank is that not everyone qualifies. you need to make certain that you have got good branding that you do work a large proportion of the UK ideally working nationwide but if you do qualify then it's a no- win no fee lead generation setup so in in comparison to check a trade and my builder it's an absolute no-brainer if you could only choose one of them but what I would like to throw back to business owners watching this is you don't just need to choose one you could choose all three and if all three are getting you a positive ROI I then then continue to spend money on all three. One thing I can guarantee you is that the fat rank lead generation service if you qualify will guarantee you a return on investment. So why would you ever say no to that? It's a no-brainer for businesses. But if checker trade is also generating you good quality leads for your industry and in the location that you want leads in, you should continue to do that as well and have that diversification of lead generation coming through to your business. Every successful business is overs subscribed. So you want to be making certain that you're getting an influx of quality inquiries daily coming through into your inbox. That means you can start charging the right prices. You don't want to race down to the bottom. Sometimes using some some of these trade people websites, it makes the price down a a race down to the bottom because you're getting five others. You're sharing those leads with five other companies, which then means you need to be the cheapest pretty much to win the job. A lot of customers look at best value, but at the end of the day, you're coming up alongside all your competition, where Fat Rank, you're getting exclusive real-time leads. So, if you had to choose one, my opinion, the best is fat rank.com. But I would like to throw back saying that all three of them could get you a return on investment. What one one thing that you've mentioned um and it it took me a couple uh times to to actually wrap my head around this whether we've been in meetings, we've been speaking to lead generation clients and stuff is the oversubscribed part, right? Because obviously you've mentioned before it's a good thing to be overs subscribed because you can raise your prices, you can be very picky with the the type of clients that you want. Can you just go into a little bit more detail as to why it's good thing to be overs subscribed?
Guest: Yeah, for sure. I think it's a great question to ask as well because people at first when they say oversubscribe think that's a bad thing. Oh no. But at the end of the day, what you're able to do is I think a lot of people will be able to resonate when I say this that the the pre law 8020 rule. You normally get 20% of your issues, right? or or 80% of your issues from 20% of your client base. It's the same people. It's normally the ones that turn around and want that 10% discount. Those jobs go wrong or the ones where you just do a favor for a certain customer. It's those jobs that always go wrong. And sometimes you feel, I just want to keep my lads busy, so I'll I'll just do it for this job. And it's then if you can cut those out and you can win jobs at the right prices, you don't need to cut corners. You don't need to put an inferior product down. You can win those jobs and say no. Some of the best things you can ever do as a company is say no. When you know things just don't seem to stack up or people want something at a cheaper price and you've got that ability to say no because you've got that many leads coming in. Wow, what a position you are in. And sometimes being able to being overs subscribed and say no to certain companies that just care about being cheap cheap cheap cheap just makes the business run effectively. If it's a three-day job and they're trying to get you to do it in two days, those are the ones that end up going wrong. And you know what? You get the blame for it. Even though it's them that's tried to force you down on price, it's you that says, "Well, you accepted it, which you did, and it's your fault." and sometimes being overs subscribed. And this is why I say all three, if someone is searching for check a trade versus my builder versus fat rank, all three platforms could be good for your business. But track those KPIs, see which ones are getting you the return on investment. It might just be that my builder and fat rank get you the return on investment, then just sign up to them two. It might be that check a trade and fat rank get your the guaranteed return on investment then sign up to them two but we can guarantee you at fat rank you will get a return on investment where the other two you need to be tracking the KPIs and making certain that you do get that return on investment for your lead generation. So that has been our video on the ultimate showdown of check a trade versus my builder versus fat rank. If you are struggling with lead generation, head over to fatrank.com, fill in the contact form, and get in touch with our team.